Dow+30.69up+0.29%
10,464.40
Nasdaq+6.87up+0.32%
2,176.05
S&P+4.98up+0.45%
1,110.63

MSN Money video

Video on MSN Money
This player requires the installation of the free Adobe Flash Player. Click here to download.
More on MSN Money . . .
To fly or drive: Which is cheaper? © Getty Images

The Basics

To fly or drive: Which is cheaper?

Continued from page 1

Less money, more time?

There are other choices besides flying and driving. Amtrak can be an option if you have a lot of time -- especially along the East Coast, where routes connect more big cities.

For instance, a trip from Philadelphia to Orlando in July would take almost 22 hours each way and cost $234 round trip per person.

MapQuest says that same trip would take about 16 hours by car, not counting stops. And AAA says the gas bill would be $250 in a Dodge Caravan minivan. A motel stop would further run up the bill. For one person, that might make the train a better deal. For a family of four, it wouldn't even be close, even with stops at every single Dairy Queen along the way to keep those back-seat barbarians -- er, children -- happy.

A bus is another option. Greyhound would make the same Philadelphia-to-Orlando trip in about 24 hours, for $130 round trip. Megabus is cheap (some promotional fares are $1) but its routes are much more limited, with coverage around the upper Midwest and in the Northeast but nowhere else.

Updated June 15, 2009

< previous |  1 | 2 |

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowRate it 1Rate it 2Rate it 3Rate it 4Rate it 5High
Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1 - 10 of 109
Monday, June 22, 2009 6:19:39 PM
When comparing times to drive and fly you have to add drive time to the airport, a couple of hours on each end going through strip searches, etc. and another half hour to pick up your bags. Add in the half hour to hour that it takes your plane to actually get airborn after you are locked on board. If you are unlucky, you will lose a bag and spend many frustrating hours trying to resolve the situation. I smoke. Flying is not an option. You can't smoke in the airport or the plane. Any time you have to fly three hundred miles it is less stressful and much faster and cheaper to drive.  In addition to the airfare and multitude of fees that it costs to fly, you have to pay for either a limo to the airport or airport parking neither is cheap. Food at airports is generally lousy quality and baseball park outrageously priced. Add that if you plan on eating or drinking while whiling away the hours waiting for your late plane to arrive. I don't know how much driving saves or costs versus flying. But I do know that the 21 hour drive to Las Vegas from Houston is easier on my constitution than flying. But then, I have an anger issue to deal with. I hate the way that we are treated as mindless lemming and/or terrorists when trying to fly from point A to B. I refuse to yield my privacy to BIG BROTHER.
Sunday, June 21, 2009 1:00:15 AM
We (Family of 3) recently made the trip to Florida, Orlando Area to visit my parents.  The potential air fare on Jet Blue was approximately $400 per person plus we would have had to rent a car for the 7 days that we were there at a cost of about $235 not including insurance which can run upwards of $20 per day in Florida.  We drove a 2009 Yaris which averaged about 39 miles per gallon doing about 75 mph with the air conditioner running part of the time. We used about 3-4 tank fills each way. I believe that AAA calculates the cost at about $85 each way, we stayed in SC on the way down at a very nice Ramada Motel for $69 including a Free Hot Breakfast (all you can eat). On the way back we stayed at a New Motel 8 in Virginia for about $70. While we did spend two days on the road each way we saved a ton of money which we used for a  two theme park ticket for three @ a cost of $297.00. The only drawback was I had two listen to my 8 year old ask "are we there yet" about a thousand times.  You decide if it is worth it.  Average cost of gas on this trip was $2.35 per gallon. Open-mouthed
Saturday, June 20, 2009 8:16:35 PM

I travel by myself towing a new 30 ft trailer w/slideout, polar edition with a 3/4 ton chev 440L and just take my time  and

find the premium fed. and BPA sites.   Just a little  homework

on the  maps and Internet and the U.S. is your's, esspesilia in the

new world  utilizing the  AMERO for currency.  Think of a new

country , with Mexico, Canada, and the U.S. as one. 

 

MVW250.hotmail.com

\

 

Saturday, June 20, 2009 2:54:03 PM

Our family of seven travels from central Ohio to western Montana annually. At night we park at a rest stop and sleep in the car, and for meals we usually have almost everything packed in coolers and assorted boxes in the back of the van. It costs us about $900 dollars, round trip, for the 2,200 mile car trip.

Saturday, June 20, 2009 2:38:09 PM
I'm from the Islands, and I have to take a plane to Florida and we (family of 4 (2) drivers) drive as far as New York where we have family, and it is cheapier to drive.  We stop along the way to these small towns and view/shop along the way.  If your not push for time even stopping to get a hotel room still is cheapier. 
Saturday, June 20, 2009 11:04:52 AM

 

the only way flying could be cheaper is if yoou are a pilot when

private pilots license and the commercial and instrument ratings.

Even so, a family of four could rent a Cessna Skyhawk(lowest end 4 place plane from Cessna)and not be paying extra baggage or child's

fares. Cruise speed is about 130 miles a hour; so most flights would take under 2 hours. But you'd still have to rent a car and a hotel/motel room; plus eating. With airlines, you just buy a seat. You don't fly-you're not a member of the crew-and the crew really doesn't give

a hoot how many people are on any flight-whether it's a Monday

morning, Friday afternoon/evening; or a red eye. Keep in mind that the newest crews get the least desirable flights.

Saturday, June 20, 2009 10:07:41 AM

I will be nice to RoadWarrior and not comment on how they eat. But I will comment on his intent that no body can eat at McD's for 4 for $20 Much less $40 each way. You ever hear of the $1 VALVE MENU? There are at least TEN things on it. Here is a sample of what a familiy of four might and CAN do with the $1 menu.

 

Person (A/C)

(2) McDoubles

(1) Mickey D's tea (sweet or unsweet,and you can get soda if your not a moron and be obvious) 32oz foam to go cup and refills at drink station

(1) **** fry

 

Person (B/D)

(2) McChicken sandwishes

(1) Mickey D's Tea (like above too)

(1) **** fry

 

$16 + 7% tax = $17.12 for meal for 4

 

Please note you can substitute TWO chicken nuggets/strips (depends on area and what they offer) for the McDouble's or McChicken's on the $1 menu as well. You can also add to the meal on top of it all or just plain substitute apple pies (2 for $1) for frys.    

 

Add eight pies and you get a $21.40 with tax meal for 4

Add four pies and you get a $19.26 with tax meal for 4

 

Subsitute pies for any frys in any combo version of the meals above and you get a meal for 4 that cost with tax $17.12-$21.40

for 4 that cost with tax, But RoadWarrior tells you it can not be done right? That is alot of food for $21.40! OINK OINK if not to you and yours for the each way road trip meal. Think about it people. With ten items on the $1 menu you can mix and match and make something work. This was but ONE version and idea for it. Eat all McDoubles or all McChickens. Or all Chicken nuggets/strips. Eat no pies and eat the ice cream. Still for $17.12-$21.40! 

Wednesday, June 17, 2009 10:18:35 PM
I live in PA and figured out our trip to Orlando last year was cheaper driving than flying. Besides trying to pack all the kids stuff you can't carry the extras. You have to either buy or rent things like umbrellas. Its ok for adults to fly but with kids better off driving. Also don't forget all those extra gotchas when flying with kids. You either need to fly and carry the car seats to put in a rental or get dinged and extra 20 bucks a day per car seat (19.00 plus taxes times 2) plus all the fees. A 1 week rental cost me more than all the gas round trip and the few meals.
Wednesday, June 17, 2009 6:30:31 PM
It's all about what you are driving and how many people are in it.  2 folks in a midsize?  Fly if the deals are decent.  4-5 folks in a high-mileage car (compact hybrid, modern diesel, or something like an Aveo), drive if you have time.  If you can get 7 or 8 into something that is not so efficient, you can still make it work.
Wednesday, June 17, 2009 5:45:14 PM
Yeah, zig, I didn't mind the changes in weather patterns recently...  70 degree days in June in the SoCal deserts, when it is normally in the 90s.  I think I like this Global Warming (oh, excuse me, since it has gotten colder, they changed the name, didn't they...)
1 - 10 of 109
To add a comment, pleasesign in