MSN Money video

Video on MSN Money
This video requires the installation of the free Adobe Flash Player
More video on MSN Money . . .
Jon Markman

SuperModels3/17/2009 12:01 AM ET

Market rally just misguided optimism

Don't get excited about the past week's rally. The bear market's keys -- tumbling demand and the death of credit securitization -- aren't likely to improve soon.

By Jon Markman
MSN Money

Stocks scorched the sky in impressive fashion last week, starting with a 379-point Dow rocket Tuesday and proceeding with the sort of jubilant, eat-my-shorts swagger that has characterized the start of many new bull markets of the past.

Bravo, well done, and quite a relief. But enough to signal an end to the 17-month capital attack that has blown up $50 trillion in market value and blistered many investors' professional reputations? Not a chance, as well-armed bears in police uniforms are just itching to give out tickets to investors trying to break the laws of financial gravity.

The roots of the advance were suspect, and undeniable earnings and credit disasters still lie ahead. The previous 23 times that 5%-plus up days for the market have followed massive one-year declines all came in the ever-hopeful but share-bleeding Depression years of 1931 and 1932. The market may well rally 12% more to the February highs, but bulls shouldn't send out party invitations just yet. Expect the rally to fizzle out by the end of this week or next, or, in a stretch, by the start of April.

Why so glum? Bad news that hasn't hit stock markets is like a case of embezzlement; in both cases the victim can believe he has access to funds for a long time even though they are actually gone. Bear markets are thus like a long forensic investigation of what economist John Kenneth Galbraith called the "bezzle," the plundered funds.

Bears take a break, sharpen claws

Catalysts for the rally were patently absurd. The kickoff event last Tuesday, March 10, was an announcement by Citigroup (C, news, msgs) that it had earned a profit in the first two months of the year -- as long as you don't count loan write-offs or other losses. That's like saying Death Valley is temperate except for the heat.

There was also word out of Congress that legislators wanted to suspend much-hated mark-to-market accounting rules -- but then acknowledged it's really the call of the Securities and Exchange Commission, which quickly said it would do no such thing. And then Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner told reporters that the Obama administration planned to do what was necessary to fix the economy -- yet unfortunately plans from his understaffed department are still all they've got.

A week earlier, the market would have fallen apart on this bland news. So why the big rally March 10? The smug answer revolves around supply-and-demand nuances. But the sassy answer is that the bears are sort of like a thug who has been pounding a victim for hours and needs to take a break to ice his knuckles. This is just a timeout. The beatings will continue until morale improves.

Let's get the facts straight: The bear market has not been about panic or psychology; it's been about plunging demand and the death of credit securitization. Neither shows any signs of improving in the next six months. Retail sales for 2008 were off 10.4%, a plunge equaled in the past 60 years only by July 1951, according to analyst Philippa Dunne. In February, just 6% of respondents in Dunne's monthly survey of state officials hit their targets for sales-tax collections, down from 21% in January. Said one official: "I have been doing this 25 years, and I never thought I would see broadly and consistently declining sales-tax receipts."

Home prices are now declining at their fastest pace ever, according to ISI Group analysts. Since those declines are coming at the same time stock prices have plunged, credit has re-tightened, and unemployment is accelerating. Among smart independent economists, gross domestic product growth forecasts for 2009 are going negative, down from prior expectations of flat to 1% growth. And next year is looking much worse: An analysis by ISI, which has been right on the money so far, shows the country likely to lose 4 million more jobs by the end of 2010 to reach an 11% unemployment rate. In the past two recessions, 2001 and 1990-91, employment didn't start to grow until one to two years after the first quarter of GDP growth.

Video on MSN Money

Jim Jubak
The end of the 401(k) match?
As workers try to rebuild decimated retirement portfolios, companies have started cutting the match on employee contributions, MSN Money's Jim Jubak says. (March 12)

Making the housing problem more acute are forecasts that the next leg down will slam areas such as New York and Seattle, where prices are down only 15% from their peaks so far. In areas like California, where prices are down 50%, sales are actually surging from very low levels, but part of the reason is that foreclosure dumping has created stunning bargains that also cut marginal pricing further.

Some good news: If home prices fall 10% more nationwide and mortgage rates stay on track to hit 4.75%, housing affordability, already at a record high in January, will rise an additional 20%, setting the stage for a robust recovery in a couple of years.

Commercial property vacancies are on track to hit 18% by the end of the year.

Continued: Too much Obama drama

 1 | 2 | next >

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowHigh

MSN Money poll