Dow+150.25up+1.52%
10,058.64
Nasdaq+24.82up+1.17%
2,150.87
S&P+13.78up+1.30%
1,070.52

MSN Money Video

Video on MSN Money
This video requires an updated version of the free Adobe Flash Player.
More video on MSN Money
Gold © Comstock Images/Jupiterimages

Extra11/17/2009 8:32 PM ET

Will silver outshine gold?

Sure, gold costs a lot more and gets most of the attention, but its white-metal sister could be the better buy today.

[Related content: stocks, metals and mining, ETF, gold, currencies]
By MarketWatch

Silver is not so much a poor man's gold anymore, and investors might soon realize that the white metal is the real treasure.

True, at $17 an ounce, silver is cheap, trading around a 65th of gold's record price of more than $1,100. But this year it has climbed 52% in value compared with gold's rise of about 25%, according to FactSet Research.

Silver is a precious metal, after all, one that historically has outperformed gold in a bull market and doubles as an industrial metal. And supplies are declining much faster.

"Silver is unique in terms of being both a monetary and an industrial metal," the Bullion Services Team at GoldCore said in a recent report, pointing out that silver is severely undervalued. "Silver remains the investment opportunity of a lifetime."

Gold prices have climbed nearly 11% in the past two months, while silver has risen by only 3.1%.

And "investors looking for returns continue to wager on higher gold prices, whether it be on concerns over equity or currency markets . . . or to make quick short-term profits," according to CPM Group's latest Precious Metals Advisory.

But investors would be better served to turn their eye toward silver.

Silver glistens, too

"Silver is highly correlated to the safe haven of gold and is, in effect, a leveraged sister of the precious yellow metal," according to GoldCore, an international bullion dealer. "Thus, informed investors use gold more for wealth preservation purposes and silver in order to make a return."

That's particularly important to keep in mind as investors change the way they perceive the paper-asset markets.

As stocks, currencies, bonds and other paper assets have begun to disappoint investors, investor attitudes have been shifting, said Mark Leibovit, the chief market strategist for VRTrader.com.

"What begins as a trickle ends as a tidal wave when the panic peaks. When public revulsion at the U.S. dollar begins, the tidal wave will become a tsunami," he said.

Under that scenario, "silver, far more volatile than gold, will benefit most."

Silver over gold?

Forced to pick just one, Chris Mayer, the editor of Agora Financial's Capital and Crisis, said he'd rather own gold, though other people disagree.

"Silver does not have the same appeal as gold," Mayer said. "What did India's central bank buy in record amounts . . . (and) what did China double its reserves of this year? Gold. They aren't buying silver.

Video: Good tidings for silver

"It's not like comparing oil with (natural) gas, where you are comparing the energy equivalent of the two and there is some economic incentive when the gaps get very wide to switch to one or the other at the margin," Mayer said. "That doesn't exist with silver and gold."

And when the global industry remains mired in a slow growth pattern, the market is not going to see sky-high prices for a metal whose "lion's share of demand comes from its industrial applications," said Jon Nadler, a senior analyst at Kitco Metals.

It's really silver's "precious side that is holding it up right now," said Ed Bugos, the director of mining finance at Strategic Metals Research and Capital. "Its industrial side would be overvalued" with the ratio of silver to other commodities having reached new highs.

Silver as a hedge

The investment figures for silver show this loud and clear.

"Silver's allure as an investment is ever more appealing as a hedge against fading fiat currencies that are getting inflated into oblivion," said Scott Wright, an analyst at financial-services company Zeal.

This is "measurable via skyrocketing investment demand" for physical bullion and exchange-traded funds, he said, pointing out that the iShares Silver Trust (SLV, news, msgs) exchange-traded fund has already increased its holdings 29% in 2009.

From the start of this year through October, total silver holdings in exchange-traded funds were up 36.3%, according to data from CPM Group.

Continued: Gauging demand

 1 | 2 | next >

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowRate it 1Rate it 2Rate it 3Rate it 4Rate it 5High
Fund data provided by Morningstar, Inc. © 2009. All rights reserved.
StockScouter data provided by Gradient Analytics, Inc.
Quotes supplied by Interactive Data.
MSN Money's editorial goal is to provide a forum for personal finance and investment ideas. Our articles, columns, message board posts and other features should not be construed as investment advice, nor does their appearance imply an endorsement by Microsoft of any specific security or trading strategy. An investor's best course of action must be based on individual circumstances.
Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1 - 10 of 17
Tuesday, November 17, 2009 9:44:41 PM
Bottom line is you can't print silver or goldOpen-mouthed
Demand will soon pass production soevan if it dips $100.00 this timenext year it physical will be HARD to get, BUY SILVER and OR GOLD NOW. Evan at todays price it is a DEAL.
Ps China is telling it's population to buy metal including silver !

Wednesday, November 18, 2009 6:44:23 AM
Well, I will admit that I just don't know ... b u t .... it sure seems to me like the Gold or Silver rush is akin to building bomb shelters and stocking up on food in the Mid Sixties for fear of Missiles from Cuba. 

I believe that the U.S. economy will rebound, and I would rather have my investments in selected solid diverse equities.  
Wednesday, November 18, 2009 6:59:40 AM
Looks like I am going to buy Sliver... cheaper and quicker return, Gold is to high right now.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009 7:43:34 AM
wsilver is normally a fantastic deal, and often follows what gold does, but $18 an ounce with an uncertain january is not the same investment as it was earlier in the year when silver was less than $10...
Wednesday, November 18, 2009 8:41:04 AM

once again we see one blunder open the door for another. over spend the paper dollar to a point of almost total worthlessness then chase gold and silver only to sell them and obtain more worthless money. in the past those who purchased gold often did so when it was on the high end and ended up either selling at a loss or keeping it with the hopes of another upswing.

 seems to me that if they would have invested in the stock market with mutual funds that they would be ahead. fear of missing the ship always sends us into a gold rush. the only way you'll get ahead with acquiring gold is to dig or pan for it

Wednesday, November 18, 2009 8:54:59 AM
Sliver is way undervalued and there is now a shortage. It will easily top $50 over the next few years and on it's way to $100. Of course, gold will be heading for $3,000.
#7
Wednesday, November 18, 2009 9:08:16 AM

Check Nelson Bunker Hunt and William Herbert Hunt. Google these Mallards.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009 9:16:38 AM

I've been collecting silver coins all of my life because it's cheaper than gold. But keep in mind that silver and gold can both take huge negative and posative swings.

 

In the 80's, silver went from $50/oz. to $4/an ounce in 5 or 6 years.

At $17/oz., I personally would like to see the price come down a little before I purchased anymore, and have even had the thought of cashin in.

 

I guess only the future will tell. But I'm sure those people who purchased at $50/oz in 1980, were not feelin to wise a couple years later.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009 9:17:14 AM
Buy oil, when the world econ recovers you'll be putting oil in your gas tank and not precious metals!  Gold is about at its peak!  We know oil is nowhere near it!  Buy a good oil co with a dividend or buy the commodity if you please!  There will be atleast 1 more big run up in oil before people get serious about alternative ways to fuel their cars, and wait until the chinese start driving cars in mass!
Wednesday, November 18, 2009 9:41:45 AM
Even panning or digging for it cost much more than you profit if done on a small scale such as going to the wilds and personnally seeking it. Cost for camping out and special foods water and tools you get into a problem like old prospectors had getting a grub stake, you may end up starving and being coyote food.
1 - 10 of 17
To add a comment, pleasesign in