Bill Fleckenstein: Inflation, deflation, stagflation -- which hits hardest?

Contrarian Chronicles9/3/2010 6:00 PM ET

Inflation, stagflation and you

How can you navigate the threat of the 'flations'? One option is to follow the yellow brick road and buy gold.

By Bill Fleckenstein
MSN Money

As we head into the homestretch of summer, deflation seems firmly entrenched as the prominent financial theme of the moment, even while, in my view, two other possible outcomes have a higher likelihood: inflation and stagflation.

In effect, that has created an additional theme: how best to protect yourself and your money. I think everyone should be aware of, if not actively pondering, the impact of these phenomena, as well as planning how to manage the risks that the likelier "flations" pose to one's financial well-being.

What's up? Only the things you need

Concern over deflation, Wall Street's current favorite "phantom menace," has reached near hysterical levels lately, so it was interesting to note that the Producer Price Index for July had gained more than 4% year over year.

In addition, regarding the Consumer Price Index, Jim Stack made the point in his most recent newsletter that the first half of 2010 had seen a 2.1% annualized increase -- this from a highly publicized statistic that everybody and his brother knows understates inflation. That's not to say that certain items haven't declined in price, but such a reading from the CPI is obviously not your grandfather's deflation.

Meanwhile, both The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times carried substantial articles about inflationary pressures on their websites Aug. 25.

The Times story, headlined "AARP says brand-name drug prices up 8% in 2009," starts by noting: "A new report on retail prices of brand-name drugs shows that the 217 products most used by older Americans increased by an average of 8.3 percent during 2009, the largest increase in years."

Meanwhile, in The Journal, "What's the beef? Food-inflation fears" was the headline that caught my eye. The article begins: "Cattle prices are soaring toward records, pushing up the cost of beef in grocery stores and adding to the risk of a broader wave of food inflation." In addition to meat, there are plenty of foodstuffs, including coffee, cocoa, barley and wheat, as well as nonedible products, such as cotton, that have been soaring in price.

The fact is that the cost of living is rising on many fronts, including almost anything touched by a government entity, where taxes and use fees continue to ratchet up. Of course, none of the items that are increasing can be linked directly to monetary policy, so folks continue to look at (declining) asset prices, which are more closely aligned with monetary policy, and see the environment as one of deflation. Yet if they looked at their checkbooks, they would have a completely different opinion.

The irony is that these same people didn't consider rising asset prices during our dual bubbles to be signs of inflation.

As I said two weeks ago, I believe it is more likely that we are in for a period of stagflation, which is an entirely different world from deflation. With stagflation, interest rates eventually rise, and bonds do poorly. Companies benefit when they have pricing power and barriers to entry that keep potential competitors away, as do companies that are growing rapidly.

In such an environment, people eventually come to understand that their paper money is depreciating in value over time, so stores of value (which protect against the impact of government money printing), such as gold, benefit as well.

Continued: Is gold really the Fed's guilty treasure? 

More from MSN Money

 1 | 2 | next >

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowHigh
26Comments
9/16/2010 1:52 PM
avatar

I think Gartman is usually pretty reasonable, but you are right, Bill, he''s all wet on this idea of the Fed using the gold price as a guide to monetary policy.  If gold goes below $1150, how exactly are they supposed to ease?  At least Gartman is not as wet as Steve Forbes, who keeps saying that the Fed should "mop up excess liquidity" (by buying bonds) until gold falls to its "proper" price of $900.  Only problem is the year before the "proper" price was $800.  Before that it was $700, then $600 (when I stopped subscribing), all the way down to $350 about 5 years ago.  The whole time, he and his cronies were urging the same old, stay-the course "buy and hold" equity strategy, which has gotten you bupkiss for the last ten years.

 

Keep up the good work. 

9/11/2010 10:42 AM
avatar

The current situation is not inflation or deflation or stagflation. It is called youflation. Everything you own are in delaftion (such as house), everything you want are inflation (such as food and oil).

9/09/2010 12:19 PM
avatar

Inflation is a subjective term. Here's some food for thought in regard to inflation.

 

In the 1960's an electric typewriter was over $1,000 and computers were out of reach of anyone but the goverment and huge corporations.

 

Today for under $500 you can have both all wrapped up into a thing called a notebook PC. You can buy a color printer to get your typing done for under $50.

 

So much for inflation.

 

It's easier to whine than it is to work. That's why most people whine.

 

9/09/2010 12:12 PM
avatar

Bill;

 

Keep up the good work. I maintain a diversified and balanced portfolio. I am not wealthy nor am I poor. I did not panic during the market crash because thanks to people like you and my own intuitive insight I saw it coming from 10 miles away.

 

The price of gold is a small issue compared to the real issue facing Americans today. Our government and all of it's employees are living well off of our backs and we are all suffering in one form or another. Anyone employed by the government has job security and benefits including a grand pension plan that would be envied by 90% (99.9% of all statistics are made up) of working Americans. When are we going to level "that" playing field or is it even possible at this point? How many people currently working for the government went in with the attitude "if you can't beat em join em"?

 

Follow the rule that has stood the test of time,, maintain 8-10% of your investments in gold and sleep well at night, every night.

 

PS Owning gold doesn't make you a gold bug it makes you smart at times and dumb at other times. When gold is down, I have some other holding that's up. It's not rocket science. It just takes patience and a little understanding.

 

There are only two times the price of any asset matters, the instant that you buy and the instant that you sell. It's important to remember that what you are buying and selling with also goes up and down in value,, the US dollar is not stable by any stretch of the imagination.

 

Diversify, diversify, diversify!

 

More important enjoy your life because some people believe you only get one shot at it!

 

Keep up the good fight!

 

It's interesting to read some of the opinions and predictions on here. My comments are above and I have only one prediction.

 

Tomorrow the sun will rise in the east and set in the west and in the interim many sheep will be shorn.

 

I fully intend not to be one of them.

 

 

avatar

The question is not whether deflation is a problem.  The question is when will it end!

Deflation in consumer goods prices has been in place for the last 10 years, at least.  Just look around at the empty factories and mills in your neighborhood.  Deflation resulting from Asian imports (mostly Chinese) shut those doors.  You don't have to go any further than your local Walmart to see the proof in the labels.

 

 

 

9/08/2010 8:32 AM
avatar

Inflation?  Gold?  Why not just go with a portfolio long on REO Speedwagon tickets.  This ain't the late 70's.  Look at earnings reports, who's been making money?  Discounters.  Fast food.  Auto sales sponsored by government subsidies to make them cheap.  Cheap is the operative word.  Sure, you can play hell with your prices, but then nobody buys.  And when consumer spending slows, they ask why is nobody buying?  The one salient fact of these times is high unemployment.  Companies that deliver cheap goods to live on will keep making money, because we're in a deflationary era.  Until the grocery store accepts gold for canned beans and soap, I ain't sold on gold.

 

This is an out and out depression, 1930's style, and the 70's-80's retreads are only standing in the way of the only known solution: massive Keynesian spending, all the while they hawk a near useless yellow metal to scalp the suckers.

9/07/2010 2:32 PM
avatar
I believe JP Morgan once made a remark to the effect that "Gold and silver are the only real money. Everything else is debt."
9/07/2010 2:18 PM
avatar
Our book "Eating on $1" in Amazon tracks grocery costs and calories.   Grocery prices are down. Very recently. I would imagine wheat will though be effected by Russian disaster.  Yea, you should ask the above commenters for articles.  Run,run widows and orphans to jump into gold as it maxes out so the rest of us can cash out.  Same thing as dot-com.  Housing bubble.  Food, even with some deflation won't drop to zero like flim-flam "gold" paper will.  Do you have $80 of food for every person in your household? (I live in Florida so we today have hurricane stores)
9/07/2010 1:54 PM
avatar
Just heard from mining folks Nevada has uncovered more gold than South Africa- Green shoot but be careful gold bugs!
9/07/2010 12:35 PM
avatar

  I struggle with the argument that there is real inflation at this time. A lot of value was lost when the housing bubble and stock bubble burst. The government will not overcome these losses in value by printing money. There are some industries that will have pricing power and will use that pricing leverage to aid in profits. However, most industries do not. Many Americans can look into their wallets and they hear the sucking sound of debt.

  As for "Gold" becoming a currency, that will only happen if the US Government begins to ask for taxes to be paid in "Gold".

  There will be inflation headed our way, however, it is going to be modest at best. I have placed my bet that Gold will lose it's "safety" status and the out pouring will occur.

  Who really knows?

9/07/2010 8:49 AM
avatar
Good article. The middle class needs sustainable wage growth to turn the economy around. Where this wage growth will come from has not been addressed by government or private companies. My guess is the rich get richer and the poor have babies.
Pretty much; the continued accumulation of wealth, declining wages, and increased cost of living, will eventually wipe out the middle class.
9/07/2010 7:02 AM
avatar
Good article. The middle class needs sustainable wage growth to turn the economy around. Where this wage growth will come from has not been addressed by government or private companies. My guess is the rich get richer and the poor have babies.
9/06/2010 9:25 PM
avatar
Please note this is unlike previous STAGFLATION, there are INFLATION Bubbles across the World in Real Estate in China, Singapore, Malaysia, etc.  And there is FOOD Inflation in Russia.  There is a BOND Bubble in America and in the US Dollar value.  This time STAGFLATION is caused by over-printing of US Dollar and not by the limitation of a commodity (eg. OIL in the 1970s).  This STAGFLATION is nothing like you have ever seen before ! Lightning
avatar
Buy a senator if u can afford it. THAT'S WHAT THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM DOES.
9/06/2010 7:46 PM
avatar

What a joke.  Put your money into tech stocks!!  And then - pour it into residential real estate!!  And now - buy, buy, buy gold!!  One bubble after another to fleece the gullible.

 

And the sheer chutzpah of those on the right who sing, "The government is spending too much; runaway inflation is right around the corner; buy gold!"  The same people who spent like drunken sailors when they were power and who drove us deeply into debt.  They lack any credibility whatsoever.

9/06/2010 4:17 PM
avatar
No, there isn't any reason to shop. Not 10%, Not 15%, Not 20%, Not Even 25% Off will get me back into the stores! How many of you out there feel the same way?
9/06/2010 1:34 PM
avatar

Lock in low interest mortgages - it will be like having free money once inflation kicks in

9/06/2010 11:39 AM
avatar
We are reliving key components of the 1970s: major elements of the standard of living (energy, food, basic materials that go into housing/rent and clothing) are rising faster. This time we can add health care and tuition since many controls for such things have disappeared in the American economy. The reality is that wages are not rising as fast as the inflation that most people care about. So, in a sense, there is deflation going on but only in MOST people's wages (the financiers, doctors and executives are doing fine) due to offshoring. Since the history of any nation is written by the top 1%, this economic reality will not be properly represented in the media, academia or historical texts.

The combination we see today is what is known as STAGFLATION. And, the failure to address this fundamental issue (not just monetary policy but economic dogma), has been driven by this failure to understand (or the failure to care about) the situation that most Americans face.

Worrying about gold prices in this environment seems like trying to figure out which lifeboat of the Titanic is the most comfortable before climbing on board instead of trying to fix the ship's damage.

PS - I see a lot of posts on these blogs blaming the Dems for this disconnect but the reality is that the GOP has been guilty of the same thing for a decade or more. We would not be here today if they did not give the nation a head start into this mess.

9/06/2010 11:39 AM
avatar
Until we manage our federal debt our economy and America are going no where.Wink
9/06/2010 11:29 AM
avatar
You're better off with mining stocks that are more than just one metal.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of ConductPlease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
Additional comments(optional)
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
viewCounter