Bill Fleckenstein: Public pensions' threat to U.S. economy; gold as a haven

Contrarian Chronicles9/17/2010 6:00 PM ET

Cuba understands what US doesn't

As even the Cuban government lays off workers, we can't seem to face the looming problems posed by our own bloated public payrolls.

By Bill Fleckenstein
MSN Money

It might seem obvious, but one of the fundamental rules of investing is "don't lose money." That rule is also one of the more important and unnoticed casualties of the Greenspan-to-Bernanke era at the Federal Reserve.

Why? Because once you stop worrying about loss of capital, lots of bad things can happen (in addition to losing money).

For those who need proof, just look at our two most recent asset bubbles. People and companies got up to a lot of mischief and were usually not worried that they might lose money. A lot of them behaved accordingly, which is to say, recklessly.

And why wouldn't they? After all, they were encouraged to act that way. And nobody did more to convince people they shouldn't worry about taking advantage of the bubble du jour, be it tech stocks or real estate, than Alan "What, Me Worry?" Greenspan.

What makes the "don't lose money" aphorism timelessly relevant, however, is that, at its root, it is about protecting yourself financially. Manage risk. Don't overextend. Do your homework. Stop and think. Know your limits. Know yourself.

As regular readers know, I think one of the best ways to protect yourself, against numerous threats on multiple fronts, is to own gold. Although I have not been too focused on it in the past, one of those threats -- and therefore another reason we need protection -- is the big problem this country faces with regard to the bloated structure of local, state and federal governments.

Does my pension make our deficit look fat?

In my Aug. 13 column, I talked about the potential for class warfare between average citizens who are struggling and government workers who have the chance to retire on extremely generous pensions. In other words, there is going to be a clash between those struggling in the private sector and those living relatively fat off public money. What I had not realized until recently was just how out of control the numbers had become.

In a newsletter this month, Dennis Gartman shared some data on the subject, which I found very illuminating: In 1949, government spending was 14.3% of gross domestic product. As of 2009, it had risen to 24.7% of GDP (and is obviously higher now). In other words, since 1949, that percentage has grown 73%. Given the problems the country faces, this is something that will have to be addressed somewhere down the road.

An econ lesson in high Fidel-ity

More importantly, it isn't just defense spending (as some would like to believe) that is the source of the increase. Gartman pointed out that in 1949, defense and international aid constituted 7.1% of GDP, while federal payments to individuals were just 3.7%. Today, only 4.9% goes to the former, while 14.7% is directed to the latter.

I suspect one thing the left and the right might be able to agree on is that it does not do anyone in the private sector any good to have a public sector that is bloated to such absurd levels.

Even communist Cuba has been forced to figure this out, as front-page articles in the Sept. 14 print edition of The New York Times ("Cuba's public-sector layoffs signal major shift") and the Sept. 15 print edition of The Wall Street Journal ("Cuba to cut state jobs in tilt toward free market") made clear. Facing essentially the same problem that we do, the Cuban government plans to lay off 500,000 workers in hopes they will move over to the private sector. As the Cuban Workers Federation said in a statement quoted in The Journal: "Our state can't keep maintaining . . . bloated payrolls."

Neither can the United States. And if a communist government like Cuba can admit it and make changes, why can't we?

Continued: A bubble in bubble sightings 

More from MSN Money

 1 | 2 | next >

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowHigh
76Comments
11/15/2010 4:50 PM
avatar
The US is in trouble and everyone has to share some blame the amount depends upon each of our levels of honesty and responsibility.  The politicians can all walk away with big F's and the banks can take those too because of all the bail out money.   You automakers are also to blame for high priced cars which are recalled every 10 seconds and taking money for nothing.  The corporations have been the downfall of this country along with Wall Street...and you crooks are still paying CEOs the most ridiculous salaries on the planet .  The sad thing is that the politicians are daily making things worse than ever.  In SC we have a stupid Palin clone as a governer who immediately put her husband on the freaking payroll!!! All sorts of behind the door things happen with politicians male and female...and they know they can get away with it because no one really cares anymore.  The public still thinks that party politics is great (hardly) and that a new politician will surely carry out his or her campaign promises....Sure thing and the Wizard of Oz was a true documentary!!!! wise up
9/29/2010 10:09 AM
avatar
Does our tax structure make our deficit look fat?  The real reason for this burgeoning deficit is the income disparity in the US and the lack of taxation for the extremely wealthy.  Reasonable taxation for the very wealthy would be a much better solution than making public sector employees poor.
9/26/2010 3:17 PM
avatar
Please be more specific.  Are we talking civilian employees or, the combined civilian/military pay role?
9/22/2010 6:55 AM
avatar
The  politicians keep giving themselves raises year after year  in this economic downturn is ridiculous...
They should NOT get any raise until the economy is doing great....
Surely, our mindful politicans can make a law to this effect.....


Government out of control....

9/21/2010 11:03 AM
avatar
Today the public companies have been hijacked by the top executives and the board members. Their short, very very short term interest is to extract as much money as possible from the companies that they where hired to serve. If the end result of this behavior be the folding of the company, then be it. There is no more such a thing as spending a life-time to make a fortune. That is why these companies are taking on so much risk these days.
9/20/2010 6:36 PM
avatar
Ask what your country/state can do for you???
9/20/2010 5:53 PM
avatar
Hey Bill the journalist... You should actually read something before your ignorant piece about Cuba being Communist. They are socialist and a different planet from the old failed and nasty communist regimes.  Read his autobiography. Read anything not coming out of Florida and the old Batista mafia
9/20/2010 5:20 PM
avatar
Is Wal-maet loosing out with a drop in customers and sales? After switching from my old main retailer to Wal-Mart a very few years ago because of saving on my grocery bill,I would now have to answer YES.I have found that the service given to me as a customer has continued to evaporate .I found that in my personal shopping  experience at Wal-Mart ,that employees no longer follow their original training.When I have asked for help now to find an item that is on my shopping list,the employees are gathered in little groups talking and do not have time to walk with me to find an item on my shopping list or the employee will just point with their finger in a direction for me  to go in that [BIG STORE].I have continued to buy an item from time to time from my prior retailer and from what some of the employees at Wal-Mart have taught me about their customer service,I'm seriously thinking about returning to Farm Fresh. Thank you for listening.
avatar
GLD and SLV (the gold and silver etfs) have served me very well. I read Fleckenstein's thoughtful articles a few years ago and having been adding these commodities (as well as oil, USO etf) and these have been more predictable and profitable then PIMCO, WFC, GS and VGPMX.
9/20/2010 4:16 PM
avatar

I find it rather frustrating that you chose to use recent developments in Cuba as your comparison point in this story. As a first-generation American, child of a Cuban father, and someone who is socially aware of what goes on in Cuba, I can tell you that the supposed layoffs are nothing but smoke and mirrors. Sure, 500,000 to 1 Million people will be laid off over the next several months, but what will happen to them? Everyone seems to believe that they will be absorbed by the "private" sector. The truth is that there is no private sector in Cuba and there never will be. What will happen will be these 1 Million people working for slave wages. Mind you, they are already painfully underpaid and their monthly supplies of food and toiletries are rationed.

 

Is that the direction you'd like the U.S. to take, Mr. Fleckenstein? I'm sorry , but I think this is a poor comparison. and your decision to recognize the Castro political stunt as something we should consider was in poor taste.

avatar

While in a tavern last week I heard a guy about 40 years old bragging about the 100%disability he had just gotten after being in prison for the last 8 years, because of "bad knees". Hardly a song came up on the juke box that he wasn't burning the floor up. If none of the ladies danced with him, he danced by himself. Guess Id be "cuttin the rug" also if I were in fat city like he was.

   True a lot of seriously ill people need help, but sick or not, here in the U.S all you have to do is retain a lawler and you are assured of a fat disability check every month.

9/20/2010 4:01 PM
avatar
I stroll through just about any Mall in America to find half the store employees talking on the cell or texting someone. I wander through the cubicles in any-office America and witness hours of internet shopping and net surfing. You expect a knowledgeable answer to your technical question and the sale person tries to read and decipher the instructions on the box right in front of you as you realize the salesperson has absolutely no clue about the product. You probably have already read the box, you could probably read better, you are more articulate, and you probably have a better idea of what the product is about than the expert salesperson you are talking to. I guess I'm the idiot here. I call any-company USA to explain my situation to a customer service representative that can hardly understand or speak english. Tips are an awarded option that is based on good service and speed, now in many places it is added to the bill whether you feel the service is adiquate or not. So what's wrong with this picture? I estimate the efficiency rating of any employee listed is 50-60% in lieu of 85-90% just a few years ago. But they gottem cheap and like anything else in this world, you get what you pay for. At one time you could trust a man's handshake; I'm not so sure anymore. Maybe I need to have my head examined. I will not buy from a merchant unless I get superior service and I refuse to tip more than the minimum amount unless I feel that I am getting superior service. Call me cheap or call me demanding but until the business ethic changes here in America my money is simply not for sale.
9/20/2010 3:36 PM
avatar
     Suddenly, we are becoming communist.....horse pucky...We had years of gambling, encouraging debt we couldn't  possibly pay back....enticed by low intererest rates only to have them sky rocket at the whim of foreign credit card holders and banks.....then we screamed....the government had to rescue the financial system....again no oversite...this is the theme of the Republican Party.....now if only we can take away social security and medicare and keep the money the old folks paid in...Ole Meg won't ever have to pony up......again the democrats have saved capitalism......we need government workers to regulate, police, and mainitain our infrastructure....folks haven't you seen our bridges, dikes, and gas lines kill people....profit exists for a reason....to make our society better, not for its won sake...wake up and smell the coffee.
avatar

The public employee unions are doing to the whole country, what they did to GM, Chrysler, Steel companies, etc......ruin it.

The union representatives are not only determining their staff levels they are determining our tax levels. All private companies have reduced staffing on paper work processing, but the government, which only processes paper, keeps needing more.    

Military spending, no problem???? what we spent on defense compared to what China paid for defense was enough to build 7000 $100,000,000 factories per year. Chump Change? we are broke and we cannot pull a single troop out of Europe.  

9/20/2010 3:19 PM
avatar
to Mungam44.  although i agree with you in part about pensions in the public sector what about the 200, 300, and 400 million dollar golden parachutes to some of these crooked ceo's and the unbeleivable paychecks that the same ceo's get my god in some cases 10 times more then there counterparts in Japan. and beleive me i'm no commie.
9/20/2010 3:05 PM
avatar
Hey, go easy on this administration. They barely have had time to turn us in to a Socialist country. It will take a full eight years of Obama to grasp the advantages to being Communists.
9/20/2010 2:48 PM
avatar
cc50, I accepted your challenge, but I didn't see any fraudulant people around me, guess I live in a more honest area than you, but there have been crack downs on cheaters, e.g., in Medicare, so somebody in government cares,  I guess you're just not doing a very good job of providing the irrefutable proof you claim to have, maybe a good insurance investigator could give you some tips, those guys/gals are really sharp at id'ing fraud. 
9/20/2010 2:34 PM
avatar
RB - You can wear out the 800 number for fraud and they don't do a thing.  I challenge you as I did LOL, it's easy to observe. Do that and then YOU call and report them and see what happens for yourself. I challenge you!!
9/20/2010 2:25 PM
avatar
garlic, ask Christie to run in Illinois, we have two imbeciles, one DEM and one GOPer, running here in November, I'm looking at retirement property in Wisconsin.
9/20/2010 2:22 PM
avatar
This is where Obama's talk about "shared sacrifice" rings hollow.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of ConductPlease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
Additional comments(optional)
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?
viewCounter