Dow+17.46up+0.17%
10,023.42
Nasdaq+7.12up+0.34%
2,112.44
S&P+2.67up+0.25%
1,069.30

MSN Money video

Video on MSN Money
This video requires the installation of the free Adobe Flash Player
More video on MSN Money . . .
Michael Brush

Company Focus5/20/2009 12:01 AM ET

The myth of US industry's demise

Products at Wal-Mart and Target may come from overseas, but the US is still the world's No. 1 manufacturer. For many American companies, there's still no place like home.

[Related content: stocks, manufacturing, aerospace, drugs, Boeing]
By Michael Brush
MSN Money

Chrysler bankrupt, General Motors (GM, news, msgs) on the brink, layoffs almost too deep to count. No wonder the recession has brought out a chorus of hand-wringers lamenting that America "doesn't make anything anymore" and that all the good jobs have been outsourced.

Few myths could be further from the truth. Despite headlines about low-wage workers in China and our factory jobs going to India -- which has happened in a lot of industries -- the U.S. is still far and away the biggest manufacturer in the world.

MSN Money slide show

10 US companies that haven't moved away © Jason Cohn/U.S. Steel
10 US companies that haven't moved away
Some of America's biggest industrial names are thriving right here at home.

U.S. workers produce 21% of all factory goods made globally, or about $1.7 trillion worth per year. That's significantly lower than the peak of 28% in 1985 but only slightly below the long-term average of 23% for 1970 through 2006.

China, the second-biggest global producer, doesn't even come close. It makes just 13% of the world's stuff, or $1 trillion worth. Japan is next with 11%. And Germany, the vaunted workshop of Europe, comes in fourth with a paltry 7.4%.

OK, so these numbers are from 2006, the latest data from the United Nations, which keeps track of these things. But China, the hottest contender for factory jobs, has been grabbing jobs from other Asian countries for the most part and not from the United States, says economist David Huether of the National Association of Manufacturers. So the U.S. lead over China in factory jobs may not have changed much since 2006.

Here's other evidence of the strength of the U.S. manufacturing base:

  • During the previous economic boom, manufacturing contributed more to U.S. growth than any other sector, Huether says.

  • Though lots of factory workers have lost their jobs in the recession, U.S. manufacturing still employed 12.1 million people as of the end of April.

  • Factory workers' daily toil contributed to 11.5% of the United States' product last year.

  • Many U.S. factory employees are big earners, which lets them consume more, contributing more to growth. They made an average of $71,000 in 2007, counting wages and benefits, or 20% more than the average of all other workers combined. States with the most factory jobs are California, Texas and New York.

To be sure, this recession hasn't been easy on manufacturers or their workers. Hours have been cut and workers furloughed. Since December 2007, 1.6 million out of the 5.7 million job losses in the U.S. have been in manufacturing. But the big picture isn't all bleak.

Not the small stuff

If the U.S. is still the world's greatest producer, why do so many people have a different perception?

Let's call it the Wal-Mart (WMT, news, msgs) effect. Most people do their "research" on the U.S. manufacturing base by turning over the tags on the stuff they buy. They naturally notice that most clothing and toys at retailers such as Wal-Mart come from abroad -- because those are two of the industries where production has moved abroad, in a big way.

The catch here is that most of what's made in the U.S. is purchased by companies, not consumers. So unless consumers also happen to work as buyers at companies, they miss the fact that machinery, chemicals, fabricated metals and other sophisticated products are still manufactured in the U.S.

Continued: It's all about the work force

 1 | 2 | next >

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowRate it 1Rate it 2Rate it 3Rate it 4Rate it 5High
Fund data provided by Morningstar, Inc. © 2009. All rights reserved.
StockScouter data provided by Gradient Analytics, Inc.
Quotes supplied by Interactive Data.
MSN Money's editorial goal is to provide a forum for personal finance and investment ideas. Our articles, columns, message board posts and other features should not be construed as investment advice, nor does their appearance imply an endorsement by Microsoft of any specific security or trading strategy. An investor's best course of action must be based on individual circumstances.
Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1 - 10 of 252
Tuesday, May 19, 2009 8:29:20 PM
I suppose you are saying that GM, Ford, the US government is lying when they say that the biggest car market in the World is no longer US but China... China has been known to fudge its statistics something it learned from America, even if China became the World's biggest producer and consumer we would not know about it unless they want us to know about it (their statistics are the same as US, all lies).  China has become the support of the World economy and although a lot of people do not know it they will replace America in the leadership position in 10 years time... I know it is hard to admit but America's time in the sun is over just like in the 19th Century Britian was the dominant power then in the 20th Century it was replaced by America and in the 21st Century is the century of China thats why we are doing everything to deny that and some of us are lying to ourselves and saying we are still the dominant power !
Tuesday, May 19, 2009 9:02:10 PM
Wow! I'm very relieved to find out that the loss of American manufacturing jobs is all a myth spread by hand wringers. I can't wait to tell my jobless friends that it is only a rumor that their jobs went overseas. I'd like to suggest to Michael Brush that he might want to grab one of those high paying manufacturing jobs before the unemployed find out about them. With articles like this he needs a new career.
Tuesday, May 19, 2009 9:15:15 PM
Let's be honest.  The last 8 years of my life have been devoted to a company dedicated to the "production" of goods MADE IN THE USA.  We unpack the boxes of product made in China, Mexico, and India, remove the label, and send them to our customers.  This simple procedure allows our product to carry MADE IN THE USA label.   The numbers in this article are not an accurate reflection of the number of employees required or the amount of time invested in the manufacturing industry.  They are simply a reflection of the profit margins.  If you have any doubts regarding the legitimacy of my claims, please refer to the requirements of listing a product as "MADE IN THE USA"



Tuesday, May 19, 2009 9:15:39 PM

This article proves how "Wall street" has its head up its u know what. They are sooo clueless. Confused

Tuesday, May 19, 2009 10:06:24 PM
Debt..debt..debt..debt..debt!!!!!!!! That's all we truly create now and it is all that has held up this house of cards we call the US economy. Consumer, corporate, housing and government.. debt is the only reason we have not paid the piper yet. You can't have the middleclass of a country decline for 50 years and say we are doing well at anything! Wages in America for the average worker have been trounced thanks to inflation and our bad trade practices ..the American dream has become just that ... a DREAM. It now takes whole families working just to get by. Even if we have not lost most of our manufacturing we did lose our earning power! Free trade has sold out America and its middleclass. We are only as good as our weakest trading partner :(  ............How could we have ever thought free trade with countries that had socialized medicine would be good for our system? and free trade with communist countries that have little or no freedom? is that not treason? How about environmental issues? We have free trade with the worst polluters on the globe but have to pay tons to protect the environment here! If Americans want to protect the environment we can not trade with these countries. We should not be trading with these countries until we have FAIR TRADE that is not at the expense of the american people!
Tuesday, May 19, 2009 10:06:56 PM

I believe the American people have finally gotten wise to the views expressed by Michael Brush and others like him. Their opinions and facts are no where close to the realities American workers face now that we have allowed corporate America to export our manufacturing base and our high-paying jobs! For too long we have heard that we need to look at the larger economic picture and not be short-sighted regarding higher profits being driven by utilizing cheap labor overseas. I hope everyone is finally realizing that there is a cost for acquiring those cheaply priced products at Wal-Mart and that cost is our jobs and future. It is high time for all Americans to make their voices be heard to revolt against these practices and reject editorial content and opinions as expressed within this article! Get wise America .... Don't buy this bull and don't buy at Wal-Mart either!

Tuesday, May 19, 2009 10:36:37 PM
The high paying jobs were not all exported...... many were given to the people who sent millions of American jobs over seas. I hope this make you feel a little better. But you know ...if all Americans retrain and go to school we can all be CEOs and bankers ......then life will be great..... don't you think?
Wednesday, May 20, 2009 4:30:06 AM
I can't even finish.  It's soooo distorted and wrong.  Average pay for factory workers is $71,000.00????

This article demonstrates all that is, and has been, wrong in America's marketplace of ideas in which the richest and most influential fashion statistical cloth with the barest threads of fact woven into bolts of pure fiction.

This article claims much without specifics and is highly suspect.
Wednesday, May 20, 2009 5:27:26 AM
OK Michael, then why are the U.S. balance of trade statistics always stated as negative?  It would seem that the biggest industry we have is the U.S. government.  It is in the 'growth' category with the main products being debt and taxes. 
Wednesday, May 20, 2009 5:42:17 AM
ennuifiat....well said comment there and very true!  It seems everyone here is pretty much saying the same thing and that's Michael Brush has his head up his a$$!!!
1 - 10 of 252
To add a comment, pleasesign in