Dow+17.46up+0.17%
10,023.42
Nasdaq+7.12up+0.34%
2,112.44
S&P+2.67up+0.25%
1,069.30
Car deaths © Brand X / SuperStock

Extra4/19/2007 2:35 PM ET

Chevrolet Blazer worst in driver-death study

But death rates have dropped about 30% since the mid-1990s, an insurance industry report says. Check the chart below to see where your car ranked.

By The Associated Press

General Motors vehicles had the highest and lowest driver death rates from 2002 through 2005, according to a study being released today by the insurance industry.

Two-door, two-wheel-drive Chevrolet Blazer sport-utility vehicles built from 2001 to 2004 had the highest rate -- 232 driver deaths per million registered-vehicle years -- during the four-year span, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety says.

By contrast, the Chevrolet Astro minivan had the lowest rate with only seven deaths per million registered-vehicle years. It was followed by Nissan's Infiniti G35, the BMW 7 Series and the Toyota 4Runner, according to the institute, a nonprofit that's funded by insurance companies.

Honda's two-door Acura RSX had the second-highest rate with 202 driver deaths, followed by the Nissan 350Z, which registered 193 deaths.

Auto makers said the study was limited in its scope because it did not include factors that could play major roles in fatalities.

"The study doesn't really take into account driver behavior or how the vehicles are used, so it's difficult to really draw much significance," General Motors spokesman Alan Adler said.

GM's Astro and Blazer went out of production in 2005.

Nissan said all of its vehicles "are engineered to meet or exceed government safety regulations as well as our own rigorous internal safety requirements, and the 350Z is no exception." The auto maker said it urges "everyone driving a Nissan or Infiniti vehicle to do so safely."

Chris Naughton, a Honda spokesman, said the company has "long striven to build very safe vehicles with a long list of safety features." He said the Acura RSX, a sports coupe, typically had younger buyers, which could have contributed to its ranking.

The institute said the average death rate for all vehicles had declined from 110 per million registered-vehicle years in 1990-94 to 79 for 2002-05.

"This is a big improvement over time. The rates have gone down about 30% since the mid-1990s," said Anne McCartt, the institute's senior vice president for research.

The study also reaffirmed past research, which found that heavier vehicles generally had lower death rates. Data came from the federal government's Fatality Analysis Reporting System and registration counts from the Polk Co., a Michigan provider of automotive information.

This article was reported and written by Ken Thomas of The Associated Press.

Driver-death rates per million registered-vehicle years:

Category/makeModelYearRate
All vehicles

79
Mini four-door cars

ToyotaEcho

2001-04

70
KiaRio

2001-04

175
Small four-door cars

VolkswagenGolf

2001-04

45
SaturnION

2003-04

67
NissanSentra

2001-04

68
VolkswagenJetta

2001-04

70
HondaCivic

2001-04

74
ToyotaCorolla

2003-04

79
VolvoS40

2001-04

89
KiaSpectra

2002-04

93
HyundaiElantra

2001-04

100
FordFocus

2001-04

118
MitsubishiLancer

2002-04

125
ChevroletCavalier

2001-04

150
DodgeNeon

2001-04

161
KiaSpectra

2001-04

191
Midsize four-door cars

AudiA4/S4

2004

14
VolkswagenPassat

2001-04

35
HondaAccord

2003-04

35
InfinitiI35

2002-04

38
ToyotaAvalon

2001-04

39
SubaruLegacy

2001-04

40
ToyotaCamry

2002-04

55
SaturnLS

2002-04

63
Mazda6

2003-04

66
HyundaiSonata

2001-04

73
ChryslerSebring

2001-04

77
NissanAltima

2002-04

79
KiaOptima

2001-04

101
PontiacGrand Am

2001-04

115
DodgeStratus

2001-04

116
OldsmobileAlero

2001-04

119
MitsubishiDiamante

2001-04

130
Large four-door cars

BuickRegal

2001-04

57
BuickLeSabre

2001-04

62
PontiacGrand Prix

2004

70
MercurySable

2001-04

71
ChevroletImpala

2001-04

76
FordTaurus

2001-04

78
DodgeIntrepid

2001-04

81
PontiacBonneville

2001-04

85
ChryslerConcorde

2001-04

95
Chrysler300M

2001-04

115
BuickCentury

2001-04

118
Very large four-door cars

FordCrown Victoria

2003-04

45
MercuryGrand Marquis

2003-04

75
Small two-door cars

MiniCooper

2002-04

68
HondaCivic

2001-04

82
VolkswagenGolf

2001-04

97
ToyotaCelica

2001-04

119
FordFocus

2001-04

124
MitsubishiEclipse

2001-04

169
ChevroletCavalier

2001-04

171
PontiacSunfire

2001-04

179
AcuraRSX

2002-04

202
Midsize two-door cars

ChryslerSebring (conv.)

2001-04

59
HondaAccord

2003-04

63
DodgeStratus

2001-04

101
ChevroletMonte Carlo

2001-04

106
ChryslerSebring

2001-04

109
OldsmobileAlero

2001-04

136
PontiacGrand Am

2001-04

160
Sports cars

MazdaMiata

2001-04

65
MitsubishiEclipse (conv.)

2001-04

146
ChevroletCorvette

2001-04

81
ChevroletCorvette (conv.)

2001-04

96
FordMustang (conv.)

2001-04

97
FordMustang

2001-04

150
Nissan350Z

2003-04

193
FordThunderbird

2002-04

37
Midsize luxury cars

InfinitiG35

2003-04

11
LexusES 330

2004

18
MercedesC class

2001-04

24
VolvoS60

2001-04

34
BMW3 series (two doors)

2001-04

35
BMW3 series (four doors)

2001-04

35
BMW3 series (conv.)

2001-04

48
JaguarX-type

2002-04

54
Large luxury cars

MercedesE class

2003-04

14
VolvoV70 (AWD)

2001-04

26
VolvoS80

2001-04

29
LexusGS

2001-04

29
CadillacSeville

2001-04

30
LexusLS 430

2001-04

30
VolvoV70

2001-04

35
CadillacDeVille

2001-04

51
LincolnLS

2001-04

53
CadillacCTS

2003-04

81
BuickPark Avenue

2001-04

85
Very large luxury cars

BMW7 series

2003-04

11
MercedesS class

2001-04

21
LincolnTown Car

2003-04

91
Small wagons

ToyotaMatrix

2003-04

44
PontiacVibe

2003-04

62
ChryslerPT Cruiser

2001-04

97
FordFocus

2001-04

101
Midsize wagons

VolkswagenPassat

2001-04

37
SubaruLegacy

2001-04

50
Large wagons

FordTaurus

2001-04

91
Large minivans

MazdaMPV

2001-04

36
ChevroletVenture

2001-04

63
DodgeCaravan

2001-04

65
ChevroletVenture

2001-04

72
OldsmobileSilhouette

2001-04

97
Very large minivans

ChevroletAstro

2001-04

7
ToyotaSienna

2004

17
HondaOdyssey

2002-04

17
KiaSedona

2002-04

35
DodgeGrand Caravan

2001-04

48
ChryslerTown & Country

2001-04

54
Small SUV (4WD)

MazdaTribute

2001-04

44
HondaElement

2003-04

49
SubaruForester

2003-04

53
FordEscape

2001-04

65
SaturnVue

2002-04

65
HondaCR-V

2002-04

67
JeepWrangler

2001-04

91
ChevroletTracker

2001-04

132
Midsize SUV (4WD)

Toyota4Runner

2003-04

13
ToyotaHighlander

2001-04

14
MercedesM class

2002-04

14
HondaPilot

2003-04

19
BMWX5

2001-04

19
LexusRX

2004

28
NissanPathfinder

2001-04

36
JeepLiberty

2002-04

46
FordExplorer

2002-04

47
BuickRendezvous

2002-04

51
JeepGrand Cherokee

2001-04

57
NissanXterra

2001-04

59
SuzukiGrand Vitara XL-7

2001-04

78
MercuryMountaineer

2002-04

88
GMCEnvoy

2003-04

88
ChevroletTrailBlazer

2003-04

108
Land RoverDiscovery

2001-04

111
ChevroletBlazer

2001-04

119
FordExplorer Sport Trac

2001-04

119
MitsubishiMontero Sport

2001-04

127
Large SUV (4WD)

ChevroletAvalanche 1500

2003-04

21
InfinitiQX56

2004

21
FordExpedition

2003-04

31
ToyotaSequoia

2001-04

36
ChevroletTrailBlazer EXT

2003-04

39
ChevroletTahoe

2003-04

51
CadillacEscalade

2002-04

58
GMCYukon XL

2003-04

59
ChevroletSuburban

2001-04

66
GMCYukon

2003-04

92
Very large SUV (4WD)

FordExcursion

2001-04

115
Small SUV (2WD)

HyundaiSanta Fe

2003-04

47
HondaCR-V

2002-04

49
SaturnVue

2002-04

73
FordEscape

2001-04

84
MazdaTribute

2001-04

85
Midsize SUV (2WD)

LexusRX

2004

18
ToyotaHighlander

2001-04

30
FordExplorer

2002-04

57
NissanPathfinder

2001-04

64
JeepGrand Cherokee

2001-04

68
BuickRendezvous

2003-04

76
NissanXterra

2001-04

82
ChevroletTrailBlazer

2003-04

102
FordExplorer Sport Trac

2001-04

113
JeepLiberty

2002-04

115
ChevroletBlazer (four doors)

2001-04

123
IsuzuRodeo

2001-04

131
MitsubishiMontero Sport

2001-04

146
ChevroletBlazer (two doors)

2001-04

232
Large SUV (2WD)

ToyotaSequoia

2001-04

18
FordExpedition

2003-04

49
ChevroletTahoe

2003-04

60
ChevroletSuburban

2001-04

90
Small pickups (4WD)

NissanFrontier

2001-04

61
DodgeDakota

2001-04

62
ToyotaTacoma

2001-04

85
ChevroletS10

2001-04

98
FordRanger

2001-04

150
Large pickups (4WD)

DodgeRam 1500

2002-04

46
FordF-150

2004

58
ToyotaTundra

2001-04

65
GMCSierra 1500

2001-04

71
ChevroletSilverado 1500

2001-04

85
FordF-150 Heritage

2001-04

118
Very large pickups (4WD)

GMCSierra 2500

2001-04

53
ChevroletSilverado 2500

2001-04

72
DodgeRam 2500

2003-04

73
FordF-350

2001-04

103
FordF-250

2001-04

122
Small pickups (2WD)

NissanFrontier

2001-04

67
ToyotaTacoma

2001-04

96
DodgeDakota

2001-04

103
FordRanger

2001-04

135
MazdaB series

2001-04

147
Large pickups (2WD)

FordF-150

2004

40
ToyotaTundra

2001-04

69
GMCSierra 1500

2001-04

82
DodgeRam 1500

2002-04

99
ChevroletSilverado 1500

2001-04

106
FordF-150 Heritage

2001-04

119
Very large pickups (2WD)

FordF-350

2001-04

50
ChevroletSilverado 2500

2001-04

56
FordF-250

2001-04

56

Source: Insurance Institute for Highway Safety

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowRate it 1Rate it 2Rate it 3Rate it 4Rate it 5High