Dow-17.24down-0.17%
10,433.71
Nasdaqunch0.00%
2,169.18
S&Punch0.00%
1,105.65

MSN Money video

Video on MSN Money
This video requires the installation of the free Adobe Flash Player. Click here to download.
More video on MSN Money . . .

MSN Money poll

  1. Should credit rules for teens and young adults be tightened?

Vote to see results

Click here to see results without voting

  1. Should credit rules for teens and young adults be tightened?
    1. Yes.
      85%
    2. No.
      12%
    3. Unsure.
      3%
1069 responses, not scientifically valid, results updated every minute.
Liz Pulliam Weston

The Basics

Teens need debt driver's licenses

Continued from page 1

No private student loans without a waiver

To understand why this is important, I'll need to give you a quick tutorial in education funding.

Student loans come in two basic flavors: federal and private. Federal student loans these days are the bee's knees: They have low fixed interest rates and flexible repayment plans. It's virtually impossible to overdose on them before you're 21, since the total amount you can borrow as a typical undergraduate is limited to $31,000. Even those college graduates who wind up in lower-paid professions, such as teaching, should be able to handle the payments. (For more, read "How much college debt is too much?")

Private student loans are another story. Their rates are variable and can soar to nearly 20%. There are few restrictions on how much you can borrow, so you could easily rack up tens of thousands of dollars more than you can comfortably repay -- and many, many young people have.

As mentioned earlier, this debt is yours until you repay it or death do you part. There are isolated, but disturbing, instances of despairing borrowers who took the latter route, committing suicide because they were overwhelmed by unpayable student debt.

What's more, some private student lenders aggressively pitch their products to young people without any mention that there's a better deal -- federal student loans -- that they should exhaust first before tapping into the private student loan market. The worst of the for-profit trade schools act as little more than pimps for these high-cost lenders. (For more, read "How did student loans get so sleazy?")

So let's cut them off at the knees:

  • Nobody under 21 can get a private student loan until they've applied for, and exhausted, federal student loans.

  • Anyone who applies for a private student loan, or a federal graduate loan for that matter, should be warned that borrowing too much can be fatal to their financial lives, and that smart borrowers limit their education debt to no more than they expect to make their first year out of school.

No zero-down, 72-month car loans

Another area where people overdose on debt in buying cars. More than 80% of auto loans these days last longer than four years, according to car research site Edmunds.com, and one out of five new car buyers still owes money on his or her trade-in.

Long loans and the absence of down payments mean way too many drivers are upside-down on their vehicles, owing more than the cars are worth, which is potentially catastrophic for their finances. (For more, read "What a car wreck could cost you").

Video on MSN Money

Invest in your children © Creatas/Photolibrary
IRAs for kids
Want your children to be rich when they grow up? IRAs can put them on the right track.

We can help make sure young car buyers get off on a better foot by insisting they have some equity in whatever they drive and that the payments suit their incomes. We should impose rules that should be common sense for everyone. If people under 21 can't pay cash for a car, they should be required to:

  • Make at least a 20% down payment on any car they finance.

  • Limit financing to no more than four years.

  • Have car payments equal to no more than 10% of their provable incomes.

Will that condemn some teens to used Kias? Of course it will -- and that's not the worst thing in the world. A Kia is a heck of a lot safer than some of the rattletraps we drove in my day, by gum. But more importantly, teenagers won't get accustomed to driving more car than they can afford, at least not while the ink is still fresh on their drivers' licenses.

Continued: Agree? Send an e-mail

< previous |  1 | 2 | 3 | next >

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowRate it 1Rate it 2Rate it 3Rate it 4Rate it 5High
Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1 - 10 of 47
Thursday, April 16, 2009 1:48:31 AM
I have seen my 22 year old granddaughter get into more debt especially on credit cards than I can imagine.  The fees are so high, she can't even make a dent in her balance because she can't even afford the monthly fees.  As a college student, close to graduation, and facing the debt she is, she doesn't know what to do & her parents and I really can't & don't know how to help her.  It is totally criminal that banks can do this to our unknowing young people.
Thursday, April 16, 2009 5:50:28 AM
I agree that teens need guidance about personal finance, and financial literacy is really important, but I think the responsibility lies with parents in teaching their kids the right way to use credit.  It is pretty mind blowing that financial literacy is STILL not a part of the public school curriculum.  Of course, it's obvious from the behavior of the federal government that they don't know possess any financial literacy themselves.
Thursday, April 16, 2009 6:44:56 AM
While I agree with some of the propositions such as basing credit worthiness on the young adult's income and anything to destroy payday line companies some of these propositions would severely punish responsible young adults.

Reasons why some of the proposals are ridiculous.
Charge cards only- In theory this is a good idea. The card I use to pay all my expenses is paid off every month and I collect some rewards yearly. What about no interest financing? Of course the morons who are swamped in debt get hurt by forgetting to pay their balance in time. I used these probably 2-3 times before 21 to make several hundred in interest by already already having the cash, but instead financing and storing that cash in CDs until the credit line was due.

Car loan restrictions- Once against good in theory. 10% is way too low though. And quite contradictory to what financial experts tell you. Look at the overall cost, not the monthly payments. Last time I purchased a car which was when I was 21 I only made 25k a year so under these ridiculously restrictive rules I would have been limited to a 220 a month payment. At the time I had no mortgage so no other bills so I got a 3 year term since it had the best interest rate. And I even paid it off a year early. But that would have been a $330 or so monthly payment which is a no no according to the author's plan. I did put around 20% down, but I disagree with that too. If credit worthy enough for free financing(semi common these days) no way should you put money down. And you should probably extend the term as long as possible as well.


Basically my main gripes are locking it down too much. I believe Dodd's plan does enough to deter and maybe educate the financial illiterate without handcuffing the people who know how to handle their finances young.


Thursday, April 16, 2009 6:55:27 AM

Hi liz,

My oldest daughter has those private college loan through sallie mae. her total loans are 54,000 when it came to lite that none of them could be combined and what was happening we saved our youngest daughter from this awful catastrophe. she now only has 11,000 in debt and is out of school working in a great job. But for our oldest daughter she keep getting this statement with the payment lower and lower i took a look and then called them to discuss this, they are billing her on a monthly basis for only the interest payment but no where does it state that to top it off it is working just like a credit card, i dont think i could handle a credit card with 13 percent interest for 54,000 either. I cannot see how they cannot give this a set payment and state how many years just like a personal loan, but had i not looked at it and questioned it she would just have been paying interest for the rest of her life with nothing disappearing on her balance. I then told her to pay every two weeks, divide the payment in half so that it will go down faster saving her more interest, but i warn everyone about these loans i wish i could tell anyone going to school do all u can to pay as you go work hard i know it is hard to work and go to college but our youngest did this and has a lot less debt and don't take out private loans unless you want to pay interest the rest of your life. I am so angry over this issue i think there should be some kind of legislature against this.

Thursday, April 16, 2009 7:23:44 AM
Why 21 years not 31 or 61?? People are adult and need to start their own family. They need to have possibility to be on their own. This type of discrimination produce childishness in citizens. I am 53 and my sons are 19 and 21 they are good enough to be not discriminated.
#6
Thursday, April 16, 2009 7:39:21 AM

I always get upset about articles like this, for one reason only.  18 is the age that has been picked for adulthood in this country.  At 18 people can vote and die for this country in war, but not get a credit card?  I think the infantalizing of this countries young adults is a big social problem.  If the media and parents continue to refer to anyone under 30 as a child and treat them as such, when will they grow up? 

 

Up until very recently people got married at 18, bought houses and had children and were grown ups from the day they graduated high school. Now people aren't considered to be fully adults until closer to 30.  How many people refer to people in their 20s as children?  If we keep following this trend in a few generations, people in their 30s will be children to and 40 will be the new age for adulthood. 

 

If people worked with teenagers to get them ready for the world at age 18 and quit trying to keep young adult as old teenagers, things would improve.  If 20 somethings didnt expect to be treated like kids, with mommy and daddy bailing them out, cause they're just babies after all, maybe they wouldn't run up the debt in the first place! 

 

If 18 is old enough to die, its old enough to have a credit card, and be responsible.  You just have to start teaching them about debt and money at 13 and 14.  Don't wait til there 18 and send them out clueless.  21 is arbitrary and insane.   

Thursday, April 16, 2009 8:16:16 AM

Kid's driving beat up old cars was considered normal until about 15 years ago.  Now the cars in the sudent lots are nicer then in the teachers lot.  My twins share a '96 Saab convertible that runs great and all I get is grief that it's an old car and they have to shareit.  It has air bags and is safer then the old Volkswagens I drove. 

 

Parents who buy their children new cars are only setting them up problems or disappointment when they can't afford a similar cars when it's their turn to pay the bills.  Yes, I have turned into my father, deal with it!

#8
Thursday, April 16, 2009 9:28:12 AM
If you are old enough to die for our country, you are old enough to not have people tell you what to do with your money.  Also, I believe you are old enough to drink.  Unless they change the age at which we consider people to be adults (and serve in our wars) then they should not make restrictions on the way people manage their lives.
Thursday, April 16, 2009 10:24:41 AM

Finances should be a mandatory class in high school.  Not all parents are responsible enough to provide guidance and sometimes not knowledgeable enough with their own finances.

Colleges should NOT be allowed to receive kickbacks on student loans.  Some have repeatedly promoted private student loans when federal loans and even grants have been available.  Many do not explain to the student the difference and the student is often under the  misunderstood idea that their financial advisor has their best interest in mind.

Thursday, April 16, 2009 11:09:10 AM

I believe that the mandatory finance class is a very good idea.  If they had even had this as a volountary class at my highschool I would have signed up for it!  I also agree with waiting until a person is 21 to give them the full responsibility of having a credit card.  I didn't rack up much debt in college, but it was enough to have creditors calling me and making me not want to answer my phone on a daily basis.  Not something that a student should be dealing with while trying to finish out their schooling.

1 - 10 of 47
To add a comment, pleasesign in