Dow+30.69up+0.29%
10,464.40
Nasdaq+6.87up+0.32%
2,176.05
S&P+4.98up+0.45%
1,110.63

MSN Money Video

Video on MSN Money
This video requires an updated version of the free Adobe Flash Player.
More video on MSN Money
Credit report © Spohn Matthieu/Jupiterimages

The basics

The new math of FICO credit scores

Those with small blemishes on their record should benefit from the FICO 08 scoring change, while high-risk borrowers and those who "piggyback" are the likely losers.

By MarketWatch

Even the most responsible borrowers slip up sometimes.

Maybe a utility bill went unpaid after you moved and the missed payment went into collections. Or perhaps there are unpaid library fines or parking tickets in collections that are hanging onto your credit history and affecting your FICO credit score, which is widely used.

With the newest version of the FICO credit-scoring system, however, minor delinquencies are now overlooked in calculating creditworthiness.

Under the updated scoring model, called FICO 08, small missed payments lingering in collections with original amounts of $100 or less will no longer do damage to your credit score.

Consumers also are less likely to be penalized for any single delinquency if it occurred two or more years ago -- and if their credit history is otherwise unblemished, says FICO (formerly Fair Isaac), which developed the FICO scoring system.

"There's more flexibility with missing a payment," said Careen Foster, the director of global scoring product management for FICO. "If you have a more habitual pattern of paying accounts late . . . you're more likely to get penalized for that."

If a consumer's credit usage is high, that will be more likely to hurt his or her score with FICO 08. But getting close to your credit-card limits -- even if you always pay on time -- is penalized in some way in every FICO score, not only the recent edition, Foster said.

The new system has been available at all three credit bureaus -- Experian, TransUnion and Equifax -- since last month.

The changes were made to provide lenders with a better risk assessment of borrowers, said John Ulzheimer, the president of consumer education for Credit.com, a consumer education and advocacy site. FICO decided that one small library fine didn't really predict whether a consumer was likely to default, for example.

With the changes, individuals who pose a low credit risk will probably see their scores rise a bit, and those who are high risk could see their scores drop, he adds.

FICO 08 also addresses "piggybacking," a practice used by credit-repair companies to help people improve their scores, Ulzheimer said. In piggybacking, an individual pays to become an authorized user on a stranger's account. The account holder gets paid for allowing the person to be associated with the account, and the new authorized user is able to improve his or her credit score.

"It was a practice to . . . misrepresent what your credit looks like to your bank," Foster said.

FICO 08 aims to single out individuals who are named as authorized sources through deceptive means, Ulzheimer said. Those people won't see their credit scores rise as a result. But the scores of legitimate authorized users will be treated as they always have been.

Not all lenders use the model

Borrowers shouldn't expect their credit to be graded by this new scale on every loan application. Not all lenders have adopted the new model, though more than 400 lenders are using or testing FICO 08, the company said.

In a statement, Equifax said, "Currently, many lenders and businesses are validating the new score within their systems, and adoption will vary by financial institution based on business requirements and market need."

Video: New campus rules for credit card companies

Many credit-card companies, auto lenders, regional banks and credit unions may have already adopted FICO 08, Ulzheimer said. But for mortgages, lenders doing traditional conforming loans backed by Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae likely haven't made the move yet, he said. That's because they're waiting for Freddie and Fannie to approve its use. Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae "are essentially the lender . . . they're the ones that set the underwriting criteria," he said.

Ulzheimer said he expects Freddie and Fannie to adopt FICO 08 by the end of the year. Fannie declined to comment on FICO 08; Freddie wasn't able to provide a comment prior to publication.

Be proactive about your credit

While FICO 08 will help consumers' credit scores in some cases, people still should take steps to improve their credit. Granted, it's impossible for consumers to calculate their FICO scores themselves, said Rodney Anderson, of Rodney Anderson Lending Services in Plano, Texas.

"It's almost like the Coca-Cola formula. No one has access to the Coca-Cola formula, no one has access to the FICO formula," he said.

But by being proactive, you can start to work toward a higher score, something that will serve you well every time you apply for a loan.

Some suggestions:

  • Monitor your credit reports and correct errors. Don't just look for negative events on your record; also examine your credit limits to make sure they're accurate. Credit limits that appear lower on the report than they actually are have the potential to hurt your score, Anderson said.
  • Pay bills on time and keep card balances low. Your payment history, and the amount you owe on your accounts as a ratio of the amount of credit you have access to, are important components of your score, Foster said. FICO 08 is more sensitive to high credit usage, and consumers may see a lower score if their reported balance on one or more cards is near the account's limit.
  • Take on new credit only when you need it. Some credit cards come with great offers, including a percentage off your bill if you sign up at the cash register. If you accept, make sure you're getting a big enough benefit to make it worthwhile -- taking on additional credit could end up dinging your score, Foster said.

This article was reported by Amy Hoak for MarketWatch.

Published Sept. 4, 2009

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowRate it 1Rate it 2Rate it 3Rate it 4Rate it 5High
Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1 - 10 of 444
Friday, September 04, 2009 3:52:05 AM
Getting something on credit is something that has become a necessity for many people nowadays. After all, it isn’t everybody who can buy a house or a car outright for its cash price! To be able to purchase such high-ticket items, a person would usually apply for a loan. And people who are planning to apply for loans should always remember that having high credit scores would be in their best interest. And it’s not only lenders who consider credit scores an important part of a consumer’s financial health. Insurance companies, utilities, and landlords also look at a person’s credit score to determine the rate they will charge for services they provide. Even employers sometimes consider a potential employee’s personal credit information among the criteria they use in their worker selection process. Obviously then, making sure that one has a high credit score would facilitate his or her efforts to get additional credit, a roof over the head, or a job. A person’s credit score can range from between 300 and 850. A score that is above 680 would usually enable a person to get loans, such as mortgage financing, at no trouble at all and at low interest rates.

So should be careful...
Friday, September 04, 2009 5:49:05 AM

What hand to hand said isn't necessarly true. My husbands fico score is 680 but because we had to short sale our home in California due to a job loss, his credit card company closed his account without any notice. We have always paid more then the minimum and paid it off several times. Of course if they do that to too many people like us they will suffer eventually. We will never use them again for anything.

Go Chase!!!

Friday, September 04, 2009 6:21:42 AM

The banks and mortgage companies make a mistake and they get bailed out.

Mr./Mrs. Average gets an unexpected pink ticket, loses their job, suddenly cannot meet obligations and they are hung by the FICO neck until dead..and their worth as a lifelong taxpayer blemished for ever!!!

The American people won't take this much longer!!!

Friday, September 04, 2009 6:38:02 AM
Chase cut me off, so my wife quit her two cards WAMU and Chase and Quit there checking acct.  Yeah boycot ChaseOpen-mouthed
Friday, September 04, 2009 6:38:55 AM
Other than existing on their $10 etc (depending on your state) fees I see no reason for them to exist.  Your local banks and past creditors can certainly look at your past credit worthiness rather than using these 3 unreachable companies.  I've seen scores diminish and heard the stories of people attempting to explain and also prove the inaccurate reporting these companies provide. I thinking theirs nothing fair these people are reporting only creating problems for Americans 
Friday, September 04, 2009 6:39:24 AM
credit card should be offer to 1st timers ages (18-25) with no credit score and holds a job. with a cap of $500 or $1000 to establish credit.  My son can't get a card with a job $16 an hr. and $30,000 in the bank. It's a shame.
Friday, September 04, 2009 6:52:46 AM
Finally a helpful piece for the average person.  Let's have more of this and less of the idiot "experts" talking doom and gloom.
Friday, September 04, 2009 7:07:11 AM
Keep looking around for an institution that offers special young adult programs.  If your not successful in finding one, your son should be able to get a secured credit card by using his savings account as security.  The best bet is to find out if you are eligible to join a credit union, go to http://www.ibelong.org/.  Better rates, lower fees, all the products and services you would find at a bank, and you are treated like an individual not a number Smile
Friday, September 04, 2009 7:13:26 AM

Taking care of your credit is important, but the fact that credit bureaus have an accuracy rate of onlly 60% makes me wonder how they got to be THE source for credit scores.  If a report is powerful enough to determine whether or not you get a job, how much you pay for insurance and utilities, and whether or not you deserve to have a roof over your head when you don't have cash up front, you would think people would want accuracy. 

 

And if you check your credit reports - all 3 will be different - and you have to dispute each item independently.  Plus, anyone can put anything on your credit - good or bad - they don't have to have any kind of proof until you dispute it - and even then, if you only dispute it once, all they have to say is "I'm right."  You have to actually dispute it a second time before they have to actually provide any sort of true validation.  What a great system!  NOT!

#10
Friday, September 04, 2009 7:21:26 AM
bewere those of you who have a disputed account with a major retailer here is the dope, if you have a account and lets say you don,t get a bill after opening a new account and you close that account due to bad customer service  or bait and switch ads  some card issuers will carry your card number over to the next retailer who buys the business and claim you opened a new account wich means this will trigger a lowering of your fico score this is what was left out of this article things like bad practices by retailers every consumer knows this is what creates fraud and theft but then this article dose not adress key issues like fraud as a whole when it happens inside a business and it leaves the customers hanging  on to a credit score system with the same old traps the fico scoring on this system do not help the consumer it creates a whole new way to bog us down in more red tape  a new hole that can be exploited by credit scores with a twist  
1 - 10 of 444
To add a comment, pleasesign in