Dow+17.46up+0.17%
10,023.42
Nasdaq+7.12up+0.34%
2,112.44
S&P+2.67up+0.25%
1,069.30

MSN Money video

Video on MSN Money
This video requires the installation of the free Adobe Flash Player. Click here to download.
More video on MSN Money . . .
Liz Pulliam Weston

The Basics

When a parent steals your identity

This crime is not as rare as you might think. And the betrayal (and damage) goes beyond the financial. Here's how it can happen -- and how to tell if it already has.

By Liz Pulliam Weston
MSN Money

Danielle, 28, thought her credit was pretty good when she went to buy a new car a couple of years ago. And it would have been, had her credit report not been littered with unpaid accounts opened by her mother in Danielle's name.

Now Danielle, a graduate student who also works full time, is struggling to pay off more than $20,000 in credit card debt her mother incurred. The older woman, who survived a bout with cancer, insists she would have been able to pay the bills had she not become ill and gets angry when Danielle mentions the debt.

"I feel bad bringing it up," Danielle said. "I feel like the bad guy."

Parents are supposed to protect their children from harm, but some inflict long-lasting financial and emotional damage by using them to commit identity theft.

Some, such as Danielle's mother, victimize offspring who are old enough to establish credit in their own right. Others use the Social Security numbers of their minor children to set up fraudulent accounts that the victims might not discover for years.

"When we first started hearing about it, we were shocked and horrified," said Beth Givens, the head of the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse in San Diego. "It turns out it is more common than you might think."

Linda Foley, the founder of the Identity Theft Resource Center, also in San Diego, said she almost never heard about parent perpetrators when she and her husband established the center a decade ago. These days, though, they get several complaints a week from victims or from other adults who have uncovered the crimes.

"It just keeps getting bigger," said Foley, who fears the recession and rising unemployment will tempt more parents to cross the line.

Credit issuers take a parent's word

Normally, minors can't get credit cards, because people can't be held to a contract until they're 18. But thieves can get away with using minors' Social Security numbers because credit issuers may not demand proof of age or may be fooled by forged documents.

"The credit file begins with the first application, and the information given is taken as truth," Foley said.

Any of the following can be red flags that a child's identity has been stolen:

  • Preapproved credit card offers in the child's name (although these may also stem from a bank or college savings account).

  • Calls from collection agencies, bills or credit cards sent in the child's name.

  • An addict or someone with a history of fraud -- who knows the child's Social Security number -- has a sudden infusion of cash or an improvement in lifestyle.

  • An Internal Revenue Service notice that the child's name or Social Security number is listed on another tax return.

One case that Foley vividly remembers: five children, all under age 9, whose Social Security numbers had been used by their mother to open fraudulent credit cards and other accounts. Their grandmother and the woman's first two husbands helped police prosecute the case, Foley said.

"She is a user, pure and simple," Foley said, fuming. "The children are nothing more than an opportunity to gain money she has not earned."

The extent of parental identity theft is unknown. The Federal Trade Commission found that 6% of victims identified the thieves as family members or other relatives, but the agency didn't publish statistics about how many of the credit hijackers were the victims' parents. (Actually knowing an identity thief is something of a rarity. More than half didn't know exactly how their personal information had been compromised, and of those who did, 84% didn't know the thieves personally.)

Video on MSN Money

Stop identity theft cold © MSN Money
Stop identity theft cold
Learn about the 'nuclear bomb' of identity theft protection. Liz Pulliam Weston explains how to freeze out would-be identity thieves -- and how to make sure you're not already a victim.

Unique opportunities to steal

Parents, especially those of minor children, have unusual opportunities to steal. Not only do they know their children's Social Security numbers -- the key piece of information needed to open bogus accounts -- but they often can intercept any mail that could tip off other family members to the crime. Even if their transgressions are uncovered, many can rely on family loyalty to protect them from prosecution.

A person whose parent steals his or her identity often won't file a police report, a necessary step to establish the fact that the identity theft occurred. Without such a report, credit bureaus won't erase fraudulent accounts from the victim's files.

Danielle thought seriously about filing a police report after reading one of my earlier columns about this crime, but she abandoned the idea after realizing her mother could be arrested.

"I couldn't do it," Danielle said.

A police report may not have helped Danielle much anyway because she actually had known about the first time her mother used her identity. Danielle was an undergraduate when her mother asked to use Danielle's Social Security number and name to apply for a credit card.

Danielle, who said she didn't understand that her mother was committing fraud, now concedes she was naive. Danielle believed she had a daughterly duty to help her mother, who had bad credit. Her mother went on to apply for a half-dozen other cards on which she eventually defaulted, without telling Danielle about the applications.

Continued: Not a victimless crime

 1 | 2 | next >

Rate this Article

Click on one of the stars below to rate this article from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). LowRate it 1Rate it 2Rate it 3Rate it 4Rate it 5High

MSN Money Video

Financial Privacy

Financial Privacy Home (c) Ingram Publishing / SuperStockStrategies for protecting your financial privacy.

Discuss personal finance with Liz on the Your Money message board.

Join the discussion.

Recent Articles by Liz Pulliam Weston

Search for a Liz Pulliam Weston article by topic.

Join the discussion!
Sort by:
1 - 10 of 142
Monday, July 06, 2009 1:56:59 AM
This happened to me in the 90's while I was in the Army.  I graduated high school in 1991, went to the Army, and when I came back, I couldn't get any kind of credit except student loans.  I just let it charge off, but it trashed my credit score. Despite no accidents and only 2 small speeding tickets, my car insurance is still over $100 per month.  Part in due, becuase I don't keep car insurance all the time due to not being able to get a car loan so I went carless during college and while over seas.

My irresponsible mom even blew the funds my grandpa left me within 1 year of his death back in the mid 70's to doctor shop for drugs which would had been worth about a quarter million dollars back in the 90's. Well, came the late 90's she inherited $200,000 from her boyfriend which evaporated in less than 2 years which I didn't see any of myself. I was still in the Army and in Europe during that time and was surprised my mother didn't pay off her $25,000 house with that money, but let it go into foreclosure.  That just blew me, especially after talking me into moving home from Europe where I had the Army ship my stuff to this house thinking she owned it! Ended up, I had to pay $500 for a Uhaul, rent a place, and move us in; leaving the drunkard old man she was with.
I went to college after 9/11 and couldn't hardly get a job and defintely not a car loan so I roughed it. I just hope I don't have any lawsuits gunning for me. I know I didn't do anything to make lawsuits, but my mother. She does things and then remains in denial about them as if nothing is wrong and I'm the one in the wrong when I talk about these sorts of things.  My brother was also a big thief and I believe he thieved her of all this money 10 years ago so he could buy illegal drugs.  I'm not very proud nor happy about my family situation over the years. Sure, being the only kid out of 4 to graduate high school and then college, I deserved better, but it's not a fair world. I woudl advise any young person about the possibilities of these sorts of problems as I was clueless due to naivity for many of my young years.

Monday, July 06, 2009 3:07:32 AM
oh my gosh, i did not think family members would do something like that, i always thought it was a complete stanger.
Monday, July 06, 2009 3:08:54 AM
well im not getting a roomate now. lol noway.
Monday, July 06, 2009 3:26:01 AM
My (former) wife used her young daughter's SS# number for years to re- establish credit and to escape a tax lien. She even went as far as to incorporate her daughter's name into her own to escape detection. She ran up hundred's of thousands of dollars in expenses....A real "winner"!!
Monday, July 06, 2009 7:05:45 AM

I work for a TV station that airs the most court shows for my market. One episode last season had a grandmother steal her granddaughter's identity and it went to collections. Usually these things happen because of desperation, denial and dumbfoundness in never addressing their issue(s) with $$. Even medical bills aren't an excuse for this! They can be negotiated way down or written off, but can the trust between those in a family be repaired after something such as this? It won't be easy.  

 

Now to change the subject slightly.. For my most recent credit card (I'm ditching B of A next month - GOOD RIDDANCE!) I went to my credit union in person. Unlike these prepaid offers, I had to provide much more than just my signature. Since the C U handles it as an actual loan, their criteria was baked into the smaller credit line I was granted - but - the finance charges are much more friendly! One half of what I used to pay!Open-mouthed

If credit card companies simply quit soliticising new business with these pre-paid offers and required applicants to appear in person as was the case with my new card, maybe the chutzpah that accompanies the crime and the aftereffects will vanish altogether.

Monday, July 06, 2009 8:03:01 AM
I can understand that someone would not want to report this to the police, however isn't there a statute of limitations that would stop them from prosecuting the parent? In MA the statute of limitations for most things is 5 years, so if you filed a police report I don't think they could even prosecute the parents. I would do it if it meant clearing up bad debt that didn't even belong to me. I actually know people that have done this to their children and it's sickening that a parent could have such little concern for their own child.
Monday, July 06, 2009 8:37:03 AM

My fiance's mother did this exact thing to him and his 2 sisters from the time they were in high school. I didn't learn of this until about a year ago and now we are getting married, and I am extremely concerned because I don't know how we are supposed to buy a house or any other big purchase. I actually have really good credit and I am looking into ways to help him build his without hurting mine too, but he is definitely the kind who WILL NOT file a police report on his mother. The thing is, she has actually been put in jail for fraud, and I am convinced that she has a serious psychological problem when it comes to money. She doesn't see that she has done anything wrong. Does anyone have any advice for us? Thanks...

Monday, July 06, 2009 8:59:46 AM

I actually met a mother who did this to her daughter.  Her daughter was four at the time, and she said it was sometimes the only way she could get a cellphone or her electricity set up.  She was trying to justify it when I told her that it is wrong.  She told me that a lot of people do it because they need to be able to provide for their children but sometimes don't have the means to (or something along those lines). 

 

If I had known that it wouldn't have just been hersay if I reported it and had substantial proof I would've reported her.  I wonder how that little girl is doing now (she is probably about 12 now).

Monday, July 06, 2009 9:20:25 AM
Sad but true. Sad  Not only do we teach kids in school about avoiding and reporting physical and sexual abuse, we'll now need to teach them how to access their free annual credit reports. Secret telling What kind of a world do we live in?  What kind of people are breeding nowadays? Angry
Monday, July 06, 2009 9:23:03 AM
What kind of people are breeding nowadays?

The same as always. 

 

Just those who are selfish and/or greedy are finding new ways to exploit others.

1 - 10 of 142
To add a comment, pleasesign in